What is Green Stick Masks
It is the Green Stick Masks is a popular TikTok trend of an item that is said to reduce facial acne, blackheads and dark spots that appear on your skin. The brand sponsored TikTok videos with amazing results, demonstrating their product greatly improving the look of faces in just 10 minutes of use.
In this article, we’ll look at the ingredients used in Green Stick Masks based on published research in the field to determine whether it’s likely to be successful, or if it’s simply a clever marketing tactic.
Green Stick Masks Manufacturer
There are a variety of “Green Stick Masks” products on the market, which you’re familiar if you’ve tried to buy the same items that are used in the viral TikTok videos. There isn’t one manufacturer that is a clear source for this product, and also no brand-name website appears in the top results for searches on Google.
We noticed that a green-colored mask stick brand known as Meidian was used in most of the viral videos. The most viral TikTok video about a the green stick mask, which achieved more than 10 million views, utilized the brand Meidian. The most viral YouTube video about the green mask stick has 9.5 million views and utilized the same brand.
We found that Meidian products on Amazon and it will be the masking stick in green formula we’ll review in this article.
Green Stick Masks Ingredient Review
Meidian green mask stick contains 4 active substances: glycerin Kaolin, extract of green tea and Vitamin E.
Glycerin is commonly utilized in cosmetic formulations to aid in skin hydration, but there’s not much research to support the effects. A clinical study discovered that a cream with 20% glycerin increased skin hydration in human volunteers, but the company that makes the Green Stick Masks doesn’t publish the glycerin concentration in their products.
Another study that was published within the Advances in Dermatology and Venereology journal found that topically-applied glycerin was helpful in treating dry, irritable skin. We’ll conclude that this ingredient is likely effective for skin hydration but not to treat acne-related skin lesions.
Kaolin is a form of clay used in cosmetic masks. There’s little research that supports the benefits of using clay on skin. A medical review from 2021 examined the health effects of commercial clays, and concluded that “while many commercially-available bioceutical clays possess mineral constituents found in successful antibacterial clays, they do not possess any antibacterial effects.” This suggests that this ingredient would be ineffective for treating acne, which is often bacterial in nature.
We haven’t found any medical research suggesting that kaolin clay can improve the quality of skin in humans, nor does the company that makes Green Stick Maskss share any, so we will conclusively conclude that this is an ineffective ingredient.
It is also the 3rd active ingredient, and this actually is a very effective ingredient. As we mentioned in our analysis of Hanacure’s popular face mask published in 2019, a publication from the highly regarded Molecules journal explained the ways that green tea extract could significantly delay signs of skin aging due to the inhibition of certain enzymes for skin.
The final ingredient in Meidian’s Green Mask stick is Vitamin E, which is an amazingly efficient choice. Vitamin E has been proven by scientific research to possess a photoprotective effect, meaning it can reduce the damaging effects of solar rays on the skin. They are one of the leading causes of skin ageing.
A different medical review concluded that Vitamin E was a potential treatment for inflammation of the skin such as atopic dermis and Psoriasis. Vitamin E may help reduce inflammation immune responses to the skin, as per the study authors.
Overall, we think that this product offers a relatively effective formulation for improving the appearance of your skin, but certainly don’t find it to trigger dramatic changes in skin’s quality within 10 minutes. This isn’t possible for any product for skincare, and we’re assuming that the promotional TikTok videos showing complete elimination of blackheads and acne were based on editing effects.
Green Stick Masks Ingredients List
As with many other low-quality brands the manufacturer of Meidian green mask sticks doesn’t publish the full list of ingredients in their Amazon listing, but only the four active ingredients we discussed in the previous section.
This product almost certainly contains inactive ingredients such as coloring agents, because none of the active ingredients are colored green and the product is green in color.
It is unacceptable for cosmetics companies not to publish the full list of ingredients, because consumers deserve to be able to access all the information about the product they purchase for personal use. The consumer could be allergic to an ingredient that is not active and, if the manufacturer doesn’t start providing the list of ingredients, the consumer could be hurt.
We advise against brands that do not provide the complete list of ingredients.
Green Stick Masks Better Alternatives
If you’re concerned about acne or blemishes on your skin there are alternatives to natural remedies with much more research backing than the traditional Green Stick Masks.
Red light therapy is an efficient, non-toxic acne treatment. A study that was published in Dermatologic Surgery journal evaluated the effects of red light therapy for treating acne, and found that it decreased the appearance of acne lesions by 70%.
Red light therapy involves the use of therapeutic blue wavelengths of light usually fixed to a large panel. It’s effective because the light penetrates skin cells and has an anti-inflammatory effect.
We suggest that patients consult with their doctor before purchasing a commercial red light therapy panel as it is a novel type of treatment and there are many concerns about the safety of this treatment in the long term.
The oil of tea tree has been found to be an effective topical cure for acne. A study conducted by a medical professional discovered it was proven that the oil of tea is able to treat mild to moderate acne with 5 percent concentration. It is extremely important not to use an non-diluted tea tree oil directly on the face. It should be dispersed to ensure that it is safe. The study in question employed a concentration of 5 percent, which is one part of tea tree oil for 20 parts carrier oil.
In the above-linked study, tea tree oil at a concentration of 5% decreased Acne Severity Score (ASI) for the patients 5.75x higher than the placebo.
A further study verified the effectiveness in tea tree oils in treating acne, concluding that it had a significant reduction in acne lesions as compared with placebo.
User Reviews about Green Stick Masks
The reviews for this Meidian Brand Green Stick Masks on Amazon are unimpressive. It’s rated 2.5 5-stars out of five which is low for a well-known Amazon product.
Many customers were dissatisfied with the product, which isn’t surprising given our study on the components. Some of the more well-known reviews read: “Total scam. Mask is absolutely useless. It is a completely false product. Don’t BUY…SCAM”.
A user also said “Videos lie…does not remove blackheads” Since no of the ingredients have tested for effectiveness in treating acne, it’s not surprising that people are dissatisfied that there’s not a rapid resolution of their acne.
Green Stick Masks Frequently Asked Questions
Does the Green Stick Masks Work?
While certain ingredients in isolation could be effective in improving skin quality however, there’s no proof that this product works because the company hasn’t invested in any research to prove it works. The brand doesn’t even publish the complete list of ingredients which means it’s impossible to know for certain whether it can be effective.
How to Make Green Stick Masks?
In accordance with the directions posted by the company according to the instructions posted by the brand on Amazon The first step is to apply the cream to the face, then allow it to rest at least 10 mins. After 10 minutes, once the paste is completely dry rinse it off with water and gently dry the face.
Does Walmart Have Green Stick Masks Available At Walmart?
There is a Meidian Green Stick Masks product sold on Walmart’s website, but it’s listed with a different manufacturer than the one we have reviewed in this article. There are no official ingredients and no reviews, so we doubt that the product to be authentic and would recommend avoiding it.
There are different Green Stick Masks brands sold on Walmart with different formulations than the one we reviewed, however we’d recommend staying clear of those as well because the Meidian brand appears to be the most well-liked version of this product.
Do this Green Stick Masks Contain Chia Seeds?
Certain advertisements on TikTok videos about the Green Stick Masks included chia seeds, but this ingredient isn’t in the formula in the formulation. We believe this is deceptive marketing.
Keep up-to-date with our research reviews
Conclusion about Green Stick Masks
Green Stick Masks has some effective ingredients, but it’s not a product we’d recommend as the full ingredient list isn’t yet available, and there is lacking information about the manufacturer.
It’s simple to use video editing effects to create fake before and afterwards content for skincare videos, which is why we recommend that users beware of these kinds of commercial videos that are posted on TikTok.
There is no scientifically substantiated study that suggests the Green Stick Masks can reduce acne or acne-related blemishes.
Topical tea tree oil that has been diluted are more effective options for acne and skincare problems than Green Stick Masks, based on research studies in the field of medicine.